“The absolute threshold for touch is the minimum amount of sensation needed to elicit a response from touch receptors. This amount of sensation has a definable value and is often considered to be the force exerted by dropping the wing of a bee onto your cheek from a distance of one centimeter. This value will change based on the body part being touched.” (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stimulus_(physiology))
Horses are special gentle creatures who live inside our civilization, subject to rules and duties they can barely understand. We give them jobs, and in return for their work, they get athletic health, extended lifespans, places to live, food to eat, specially developed supplements and foods and the companionship of humans and other horses.
But their gentleness, stoicism, and willingness opens them to maltreatment, from well-intentioned people as well as from those who are indifferent to the internal state of the animal.
When an authoritative clinician encourages practices that abuse the animal – or provides sanction by silence – there’s an even more serious problem. They deserve to be held accountable.
Let’s take Kyra Kyrklund, photographed while leading a clinic. In her own words, her philosophy includes ““They feel a fly, so why don’t they feel a leg or a spur? Mostly because we’ve been talking and talking and talking, and now they’re not listening. We have to train them to listen to a whisper instead of a scream,”
And let’s look at a photo of her instructing an attendee so we can understand how deep this goes…
If you’re an English rider, for instance in dressage, you may see a look in this horse that you aspire to.
If you’re a Western rider, used to loose rein and relaxed collection, you may shrug and say “well, those English riders, they’re always pulling on the horse’s mouth…”
But the reality is different from both of these perspectives, and, far from listening to a whisper from the horse, which Kyrklund claims we should do, this clinician is totally ignoring a horse whose body language is practically screaming distress.
This picture pretty much sums it up…
This is a closeup of the horse’s head from the prior picture.
Let’s summarize what you see here in factual terms:
- The horse’s nose is beyond vertical. In this position, the horse can only see the ground in front of its feet. It is effectively blind to where it is going. For a prey animal whose only defense is to detect danger at a distance and run from it, this can only be claustrophobic and anxiety producing. (photo from Equine Behavior: A Guide for Veterinarians and Equine Scientists, Professor Paul McGreevy, BVSc, PhD, MRCVS, MACVS (Animal Welfare), Cert CABC, Grad Cert Higher Ed., Sub Dean Animal Welfare, University of Sydney Australia – 2012)
- The horse is on a tight rein. According to its foundation training, this should require it to back up. But since the horse is not backing up, either the rider is providing leg pressure to push the horse forward into the rein pressure, or the horse has been detrained to the bit pressure. If it is detrained, it still feels the curb chain digging into its chin, it still feels the double bridle bit pressing hard into the roof of its mouth and hard on its gums, but it has now learned to do nothing about this discomfort except duck its head. On the way to that state it has no doubt been repeatedly corrected for trying to avoid this discomfort.
- The horse’s mouth is gaping – a sign of stress and discomfort. (photo from Equine Behavior: A Guide for Veterinarians and Equine Scientists)
- The horse’s neck is in an anatomically difficult position which is likely to be uncomfortable and which is, in fact, medically damaging. “In 2000, Dr Vet Horst Weiler concluded his studies on illnesses in and around the attachments of tendons and ligaments in horses… In his studies, he found that 80% of horses used for dressage and jumping had injuries around the attachment of the nuchal cord on the head. Horses used for hacking, trotters, ponies, coldbloods, had these injuries much less or not at all. The injuries consisted of bony build-up on the site of the insertion at the back of the skull, bony nodules inside the ligament, mineralization of the ligament, etc. These are all the inevital result of excessive stress and inflamation, because the body tries to reinforce and area threatened by rupture… In an article in Dutch magazine Bit in 2003 Het Knikje – Overbelasting van de nekpees, Weiler’s answer to the question of what causes the overloading comes as rather a shock for dressage riders – It occurs when the horse makes the highly sought flexion in the poll in dressage training. Overbending, riding deep and round, or with the chin almost on the chest or behind the perpendicular is the cause of the problems, according to him… These particular types of injuries are caused by a pulling, shearing, torquing or twisting stress on the ligament insertions. Now, remember that all horses graze, and they do it with their noses “on the ground”. But non-dressage/jumper horses had normal x-rays and skulls. Those horses graze too, so just stretching the head down is apparently not harmful. The shearing action on the ligament probably happens as the riders impose extreme poll flexion, curl their horses noses into the chest, and work them there repeatedly, for lengthy periods of time, or pull hard while doing so… ” (http://www.sustainabledressage.net/rollkur/why_not.php) The original Weiler study is discussed at http://horsesforlife.com/HorstWeilerInterview ) In addition, there is evidence that these positions interfere with breathing (http://www.thehorse.com/articles/29302/artificial-head-neck-positions-effects-on-horses-breathing)
The responses to a couple of people on Facebook who pointed out that these positions were damaging and uncomfortable should also generate some alarm. Let’s take the set…
- (clinic host): Just so you are aware, in this moment the rider and horse were on a break. At the time this photo was taken, the horse was at the halt and only playing with the bit.
- You should not give such a strong opinion from a picture that shows a moment.
- I LOVE her philosophies! She trains the horse’s mind as well as body. Don’t be too quick to judge Kyra by a moment in a photo of a horse that is not in training with her, but there to learn from her. I have her video’s and I have never seen her advocate hyperflexion in it.
- The horse is at a halt and is probably bored and playing with the bit. Kyra does NOT promote hyper flexion, and it is clear the rider is not pulling on the reins. Sheesh!!!
- If you have nothing nice to say then DO NOT COMMENT!!!! People don’t want negativity in their comments.
- She is one of the “greatest” trainers alive today. I am sorry I had to miss this clinic. I have seen her many times and yes you are right [defending poster] she does NOT!!!! Promote hyper flexion, quite the opposite. I believe she was one of the people that was instrumental in making the world aware of how WRONG, it was and is”………………go Kyra!!!!!
- Seriously? If you actually look the horse is totally relaxed and there is a tiny bit of slack in the rein as be plays with the bit. Dumbass
And to ensure that we do understand where the clinician positions herself on hyperflexion (given the above assertion that she is against it)… let’s take a panel in which she particpated at 2006 Global Dressage Forum (http://www.eurodressage.com/equestrian/2006/11/06/sjef-janssen-dr-rene-van-weeren-and-anky-van-grunsven-coaching-and-hyperflexion ).
“… Janssen’s speech was followed by a training demonstration with the pregnant Anky van Grunsven riding Painted Black (by Gribaldi) in the rollkur position. She warmed up the stallion hyperflexing him to the left and right on the straight lines. She made him really round, the mouth almost touching the chest, in halt, trot and canter for periods of 2 to 4 minutes, before letting the nose out again or giving him a break. Anky highlighted the importance of speed control, as she likes to alternate moments of intense collection lengthening of the strides… Kyrklund said that she doesn’t understand the benefit there is from keeping a horse so low and tight. “I don’t only evaluate the top horses trained on this system but also on normal horses.””
At best, a lukewarm reaction to this demonstration position, which as we have seen above, is medically harmful.
So the clinician doesn’t aggressively correct her students, is weak when on panels to comment on the topic. In effect, she gives sanction to this abuse.
Her supporters assert various things in defending this image.
One of course is that the horse is taking a break. We know that for a horse to learn or to perform well it needs frequent complete release from pressure and ideally should spend most of its time feeling it is traveling down the corridor of least pressure. This release is the “break” a horse should get and to create and maintain the self-carrying horse the trainer and rider should spend every possible moment in the “no pressure” regime, only escalating briefly for corrections, and even there, as lightly as possible. Even more so when between work in a session. To give an example of a horse taking an actual break between work in a session, here’s Lensman:
Loose rein, low head, ears relaxed but attentive and ready. That’s a relaxed horse. This is not:
Can there be any doubt about that?
Other defenders stated that the horse is “playing with the bit”. Let’s take a moment and think about that.
The nature of nerves in any creature that has nerves is that, with the exception of pain neurons, a continuous sensation will gradually disappear into habituation (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Habituation). The saddle, the headstall, the cinch – all are effectively invisible to the horse. The horse does not suddenly start to play with saddle or cinch unless something changes or is wrong.
What would make a horse play with his bit, if the bit were still in his mouth and he were used to it?
The answer is, stress or nervousness. “Accepting the bit: The way a horse responds to the bit in particular and aids in general. During locomotion and transitions, the horse’s mouth remains closed, soft in the jaw and with relaxed lips. A horse that accepts the bit does not shorten or lengthen its neck or alter its head position during travelling and transitions. Accepting the bit is generally accompanied by relaxation of the neck and body.” (http://www.aebc.com.au/definitions)
A relaxed horse does occasionally move the bit in his mouth. This is an effect of moving the lips and teeth while salivating and does happen at rest. But the mouth is closed and the lips are quiet, not peeled back from the teeth as this horse shows. A gaping mouth position is simply the result of excessive pressure or stress.
At the end of the day, trainers, riders and clinicians have a responsibility to the horse. To make sure that the horse has a good life in its work. A responsibility to stand up for the horse and for the right way of treating horses. The bad practices don’t have to be as damaging as Rollkur (http://horsesforlife.com/RollkurPictogram), or the Big Lick (http://www.hphoofcare.com/lick.html) – but however serious a bad practice may be, trainers, riders and clinicians have the burden of bringing factual information to bear in an non-aggressive way, doing everything possible to first change the minds of those who follow incorrect practices innocently, and then to point out and bring peer pressure to bear on those who persistently do so in the face of facts and the known welfare of the horse.
For a critical examination of the history of hyperflexion / rollkur, have a look at http://horsetalk.co.nz/2013/05/06/hyperflexion-neck-failure-olympic-dimension/#axzz2sDXGdS1e